In this article
Reformatting a candidate's CV is the most routine job on a recruitment desk and the one most likely to be done at speed, late in the day, with the client waiting. That is when the mistakes happen, and they are expensive out of all proportion to their size. A dropped role, a wrong date or another agency's logo in the footer does not just cost that candidate the interview. It costs you the client's confidence in every CV you send afterwards.
These are the ten I have seen most often in twenty-odd years of sending and receiving agency CVs, with the check that catches each one.
Why small errors cost so much
A hiring manager cannot see your process. They see one document, and they judge the agency on it. A CV with a role missing tells them you are careless with candidates' careers. A CV with the wrong candidate's name in the file name tells them you are sending the same person to several of their competitors. Neither is true, usually, but the client has no way to know that, and the next CV from you is read with that in mind.
Candidates see it too. A candidate who spots that their master's degree has vanished from the version you sent does not call to say thank you for the formatting.
The ten mistakes
- 1. A role or a qualification dropped in the copy. The commonest and the worst. It happens when content is copied section by section from a two-column original and one block is missed, or when the old file is used as a base and a section is deleted. Check: compare the original and the new version line by line before sending, every time, however long the CV.
- 2. Dates changed by accident. A year retyped wrong, a "Present" left on a role that ended, two roles with the same start date because one was pasted over the other. Clients read dates first. Check: read every date pair in the new version against the original, out loud if that is what it takes.
- 3. The candidate's words quietly rewritten. Tidying a sentence turns into strengthening it, and the candidate walks into an interview to defend an achievement they did not claim. Check: the words are theirs. If you change substance, agree it with the candidate and say so in your notes.
- 4. Three date formats on one page. "03/2021", "Mar 2021" and "March 2021" within two inches of each other, usually because the candidate used one style and the consultant another. Check: one format, set by the agency standard, applied to every date.
- 5. Fonts and spacing that wander. Pasting from the original brings its formatting with it: a different font in one bullet, a 14pt heading in the middle of 11pt text, a double space after one role and none after the next. Check: paste as plain text, then apply the template's styles.
- 6. The wrong name in the file name or the header. The template was last used for someone else, and their name is still in the header, the footer or the file name. Check: search the finished document for the previous candidate's surname before saving.
- 7. Another agency's branding left behind. The candidate sent you the version a competitor formatted, and the footer, the logo or a line of small print made it through. Check: open headers and footers on every page, and check the document properties.
- 8. Tracked changes, comments and metadata sent to the client. Word files carry history. The client switches on markup and reads your colleague's comment about the candidate's salary. Check: send PDF unless the client asks for Word; if Word, accept all changes, delete comments and inspect the document before saving.
- 9. Design that breaks on the client's screen. Skill bars, icons, text boxes and two columns, kept because they looked fine on yours. In the client's applicant tracking system the columns interleave and the dates land in the wrong roles. Check: single column, plain headings, no tables or text boxes.
- 10. Headings orphaned at the bottom of a page. "Education" on the last line of page one with its content on page two, or a role title separated from its bullets. Check: look at the page breaks in print preview before saving the PDF; a heading moves with its content.
Recruiter Insight
Number one is the one to build your process around. Every other mistake on this list embarrasses you. A dropped role changes the client's decision, and the candidate never knows why they were not shortlisted.
The five-minute check before you send
Put the original and the new version side by side and go through this in order. It takes five minutes for a two-page CV and it catches all ten.
- Count the roles in each. Same number, same order.
- Read each date pair in the new version against the original.
- Count the qualifications and certifications. Same number.
- Scan every heading, header and footer for anyone else's name or logo.
- Search the document for "@" and for the previous candidate's surname.
- Check the page breaks in print preview.
- Save as a new file with the standard name, and check the author field.
Put your next shortlist in your own template
The Glo CV Formatter copies any candidate CV into your branded Word and PDF template, word for word, and checks nothing was dropped. First 5 CVs free.
Fixing the process, not the person
When a mistake gets through, the instinct is to tell the consultant to be more careful. That does not work, because the consultant was being careful and still missed it, at six in the evening on the fourth CV of the hour. Change the process instead: a locked template that cannot carry a previous candidate's name, a rule that PDFs go to clients, a line-by-line comparison that is done every time rather than when there is time.
Software helps with the parts people are bad at. The Glo CV Formatter moves the candidate's text into your template word for word, so nothing is retyped, applies one date style and one file-naming rule to every CV, generates a clean file with no history in it, and then compares every line of the original with the result and lists anything that did not come across. Mistakes one, two, four, five, six, seven and eight stop being possible, and the five-minute check becomes a thirty-second read of the flagged lines.
Whether you fix it with a checklist or with software, fix it this week. Put the next five CVs through the formatter free, side by side with the versions your desk would normally send, and count the differences.
Recruiter Insight
Keep a quiet log of every formatting error a client or candidate reports, with the cause. After a quarter you will have a short list, and it will almost always point at the step in the process, not the person.
Checklist
- Every role and qualification in the original is in the client version
- Every date matches the original
- The candidate's wording is unchanged, or the change is agreed and noted
- One date format throughout
- One font, one size for body text, consistent spacing
- No previous candidate's name in the header, footer, properties or file name
- No other agency's branding or small print
- Tracked changes accepted, comments deleted, PDF sent unless Word is requested
- Single column, no skill bars, icons, tables or text boxes
- Page breaks checked; no orphaned headings
Every CV your agency sends, in your own template, in minutes.
Upload any candidate CV. It is copied across word for word, checked line by line against the original, and ready to send as Word or PDF. First 5 CVs free.
Every CV your agency sends, in your own template, in minutes.
Upload any candidate CV. It is copied across word for word, checked line by line against the original, and ready to send as Word or PDF. First 5 CVs free.

